Amazing Spider-Girl #2: Comes the Carnage
by Tom DeFalco, Ron Frenz (Marvel Comics, 2007)

In the alternate-future timeline of The Amazing Spider-Girl, Peter and Mary Jane Parker not only have a teenage daughter, the titular May, but also a bouncing baby boy named Ben. If you don't like to see youngsters terrorized, don't read this book.

Carnage is a spin-off of Venom, the alien symbiote that, in the original Spider-Man series, bonded with Peter Parker while disguised as a black bodysuit, then hooked up with someone else once Peter rejected it, beefed up and tried to kill Spider-Man at every turn. But, while Venom is insane and evil, Carnage is even moreso -- in a crazy, mass-murderer kind of way.

Of course, given the teen audience that dominates the readership of this book, Carnage couldn't really be set loose to slaughter at will. So instead it's a piece of Carnage, and his temporary human host asserts enough influence over the beast to prevent any actual killing. Whew!! But that doesn't mean Carnage doesn't have a hoot of a time with little Benjy, so be prepared for plenty of scenes with a screaming, crying child.

This book also has a few major weaknesses, not the least of which is Li'l Carnage, which was a bad idea all around. But for me, the worst moment was when Peter -- after being beaten, kidnapped and tortured -- exerts superhuman strength to break his bonds ... so he can hurry home and make a few phone calls. Huh? This guy was a big hero back in the day, right? One might think having both a son and daughter in jeopardy from a (supposedly) homicidal foe might cause him to don the old costume and attempt a rescue or something.

Still, Amazing Spider-Girl remains a strong book for its target audience, and the character has plenty of room to grow.




Rambles.NET
review by
Tom Knapp

29 August 2009


Agree? Disagree?
Send us your opinions!







index
what's new
music
books
movies